Substance and Separation in Aristotle. - SPELLMAN, Lynne,

KORTE INHOUD

'Lynne Spellman's book fits nicely within the recent tradition of Aristotle Metaphysics scholarship. (...) There is some novelty, and, certainly, some truth in the book's claim that Aristotle's account of substance must be understood in the light of what Aristotle does and does not accept in Platonism. As Spellman puts it, 'Aristotle can be seen to offer a defensible version of Platonism (1).' More precisely, substances are like Forms without the separation (suitably understood). Even more precisely, the author argues that for Aristotle a substance is a 'specimen of a natural kind, where specimens, as particular forms lacking the accidents introduced by matter, are numerically the same as sensible objects yet not identical with them (2).' The evidence for this conclusion is set forth in roughly the first half of the book. The second half contains a rather hurried and therefore unsatisfactory account of Aristotelian epistemology and teleology, purporting to show that, on the author's reading, substances retain...
1995zie alle details...

Categorie

Details

1995Uitgever: Cambridge University Press131 paginasISBN-10: 0521471478ISBN-13: 9780521471473

REVIEWS VAN DIT BOEK